| Arsenal 1 to 5 Show / Hide |
| 2 Mikael Silvestre |
| Blackburn Rovers 6 to 8 Show / Hide |
| 7 Martin Olsson |
| Bolton Wanderers 9 to 9 Show / Hide |
| 9 Ebi Smolarek |
| Chelsea 10 to 12 Show / Hide |
| 11 Branislav Ivanovic |
| Everton 13 to 16 Show / Hide |
| 16 Victor Anichebe |
| Fulham 17 to 17 Show / Hide |
|
| Hull City 18 to 19 Show / Hide |
| 18 Kamil Zayatte |
| Liverpool 20 to 24 Show / Hide |
| 21 Emiliano Insua, 22 Albert Riera, 23 Nabil El Zhar |
| Manchester City 25 to 27 Show / Hide |
| 25 Ched Evans, 27 Daniel Sturridge |
| Manchester United 28 to 30 Show / Hide |
| 28 Jonny Evans, 29 Rafael, 30 Ji-Sung Park |
| Middlesbrough 31 to 31 Show / Hide |
| 31 Chris Riggott |
| Newcastle United 32 to 33 Show / Hide |
|
| Portsmouth 34 to 39 Show / Hide |
| 35 Noe Pamarot, 36 Armand Traore, 37 Richard Hughes, 39 Kanu |
| Stoke City 40 to 41 Show / Hide |
|
| Sunderland 42 to 44 Show / Hide |
| 43 Anton Ferdinand |
| Tottenham Hotspur 45 to 46 Show / Hide |
| 46 Fraizer Campbell |
| West Bromwich Albion 47 to 50 Show / Hide |
| 49 Iglesias Borja Valero |
| West Ham United 51 to 55 Show / Hide |
| 51 James Collins, 52 Herita Ilunga |
| New Signings 56 to 92 Show / Hide |
| 66 Wayne Bridge, 81 Pascal Chimbonda, 91 Hugo Rodallega, 57 Emile Heskey, 72 Kevin Nolan, 87 Radoslav Kovac, 63 Jimmy Bullard, 83 Robbie Keane |
| Club Captains 93 to 112 Show / Hide |
| 93 Cesc Fabregas, 99 Danny Murphy, 105 Michael Owen, 108 Dean Whitehead, 103 Gary Neville, 109 Robbie Keane, 98 Phil Neville, 107 Andy Griffin |
| Fans Favourites 113 to 132 Show / Hide |
| 131 Dean Ashton |
| Man of the Match 133 to 152 Show / Hide |
|
| Hat-Trick Heroes 153 to 156 Show / Hide |
|
| Hundred Club 157 to 157 Show / Hide |
|
| Limited Edition LE1 to LE5 Show / Hide |
|